"Deconstructing
the Tao of Trip, or The Importance of Being Tucker:
A parody of
overblown academic jargon by a young Star Trek fan
suffering
the ill-effects of a recent education."
~ by Lo Pan
~
"Arma
virumque cano… [I sing of arms and of the man…]" –
Virgil, The
Aeneid
"Arcam
et supercilia et nasus lacertosque viri scribo. [I write of
the man's
chest, eyebrows, nose, and upper arms." – Lo Pan, BBSTucker
In this
essay, I evoke my own admittedly subjective response to
Enterprise,
by submitting the series to an analysis that utilizes
several
different heuristic tools garnered from the extant repertoire
of terms
commonly used in contemporary literary studies. By focusing
in
particular on the character of Charles Tucker III, or `Trip', the
ship's
Chief Engineer, I hope to demonstrate how the show's (de)
construction
of masculine identities is skewered by the series' own
salutary,
self-reflexive awareness of its own textuality, and of
continuing
post-structuralist debates about the nature of language.
Throughout
the series, Trip stands as a flashpoint of masculine
sexuality
and ideology. As an occasionally booze-drinking white
Southern
male with an Engineering degree, he is _obviously_ a
projection
of extant patriarchally-induced social inequities. None of
this is in
doubt. The real question is whether the character himself
is aware of
his status, or is an unwitting pawn of a homogenizing
project of
indoctrination into the indisputably sexist sphere of
Western
culture (not any community in particular; just Western
culture). I
think this is an important and complex consideration. In
the second
hour of the show's first episode, `Broken Bow', Trip and
T'Pol are
forced to enter the so-called `Decon Chamber' when they are
exposed to
alien bacteria during a difficult away mission. In an
extraordinary
thirty seconds unparalleled in the history of Star
Trek, the
two officers rub each other's nekkid bodies using an
unspecified
unguent, seductively embruing their raw limbs even as
they claim
to be cleansing them. Of this incident, original series
regular
George Takei has said, "I don't think it was decontamination
that they
were doing!" But if it was not decontamination, then what
was it?
_Decon-struction_.
One of the
underlying assumptions of deconstruction is that language
is
inextricably bound up in the processes by which meaning is
articulated.
All statements, however clear and direct they may seem,
derive
meaning from their implied contrast to values and ideologies
that can be
found in other statements and speech acts. Thus all
language is
endlessly self-reflexive, caught up in the matrix of
semiotic
infinite regress as each act of meaning-production
foreshadows
another. From this perspective, the decon scene is
concerned
with neither acts of cleansing nor pollution, but is rather
a
de-centring of these ostensibly polarized absolutes.
Indeed,
de-centring of the cleanliness/ pollution dialectic might be
seen as an
ongoing strategy in the series. In `Breaking the Ice',
Trip
informs us, albeit via a videotaped interview for a primary
school
class in Ireland, that all the ship's waste is immediately
recycled
into transmutable matter. "A poop question, sir?" he wails
haplessly
at Captain Archer. But by his own words, the `poop
question'
is in fact also the basis for an answer which canvasses
the
restorative energies of the ship's replication system. The waste/
clean
matter dialectic is bogus, because they are the _same thing_.
Similarly,
Trip's masculinity undergoes de-centring. If, as a recent
review in
the 'LA Times' has it, Trip is a "gym-trim" manifestation
of
twentieth-century machismo, his masculinity is depolarized
in
`Unexpected', when physical contact with an alien female causes
him to
become pregnant. The ritual heterosexual process of `dating
before
mating' is ironized in an interspecies first contact that
causes the
male, not the female, to bear the foetus. Thus space
exploration
forces Trip, in the words of his Vulcan science teacher,
Mr. Vellek,
to "challenge his preconceptions", including his
preconceptions
about his own masculinity, and indeed, the nature of
conception
itself. In space, no one can hear you scream, but also,
no one can
say with absolute assurance that he is totally masculine,
if
sexuality is construed in terms of a set of concrete absolutes
(ie. the
woman becomes pregnant, not the man).
By
extension, if Trip might justifiably be accused of being a
proponent
of colonialist aggresion, willfully imposing preconceived
masculinist
assumptions on other cultures and species, he is also
simultaneously
an example of colonized otherness. In `Breaking the
Ice', he
sniffs that, where he comes from, arranged marriages went
out with
slavery. Thus he appears to inscribe a colonialist,
Orientalist
gaze. But this gaze is continually recathected onto him,
for while
seeking to explore other cultures using human commonsense,
it is he
who falls pregnant; is held hostage; is mugged; and is
captured in
the snare of a sentient alien blob. These events compel
him, not
his aggressors, to adapt his notion of commonsense.
Like a
comic book, Trip is "laced with subtext", which, on further
scrutiny,
reveals him to be so much more than is initially assumed.
As a text,
Trip is the fictious embodiment -– the living, breathing
bodily
transformation -- of decentring. (Speaking of his body, and as
Marx would
often say to Engels, "Nice base, fine superstructure".) In
so being
(in the Heideggerian sense of the word `being'), he
highlights
the series' own decentred ontos. Billed as "the history of
the
future", Enterprise is a postmodern simulacrum, a prequel show
that
orients itself purely in relation to a fictional premise set 150
years
later, and which forces viewers at home to question their own
preconceived
notions about race, class, and gender.